A 56-year-old woman with a history of migraine headaches presented with one-month history of daily, right-sided, pulsating headaches, often associated with photophobia and vision changes in her right eye. She often woke up in the morning with these headaches and they tended to resolve spontaneously later in the day. She said she took sumatriptan sparingly, as she reported being averse to using this medication often, but triptans are generally helpful in resolving her headaches. She had no other relevant past medical or surgical history and her physical exam was benign. She was referred for MRI to evaluate for intracranial cause of headache.
Axial MR imaging of the brain with and without contrast (Figures 1, 2) showed a soft-tissue prominence dorsal to the clivus, but did not show evidence of a mass within the clivus or mass effect on surrounding vasculature or brainstem. Clival T1-weighted signal intensity was within normal limits. Sagittal T1-weighted imaging (Figures 3, 4) demonstrated soft-tissue mass dorsal to the clivus with similar contrast enhancement pattern compared to nearby cervical vasculature. There was no involvement of the cavernous sinus. CT imaging of the sella turcica with contrast (Figure 5) showed enhancing soft-tissue mass dorsal to clivus with enhancement pattern consistent with surrounding skull base vasculature.
Prominent retroclival venous plexus, normal anatomic variant
The clivus is a midline, wedge-shaped segment of the central skull base that extends inferiorly to the foramen magnum and is bordered laterally by the petroclival fissures. Homogeneous hyperintensity of the clivus on T1-weighted imaging is a normal, age-related finding, found in one-third of patients in the third decade of life. As patients age, the proportion of patients demonstrating clival hyperintensity on T1-weighted images increases across decades and approaches 80-100% in the 8th and 9th decades of life.1,2 A hypodense clivus in an adult patient should raise concern for potential pathology.
The differential diagnosis for a clival mass can be divided into three major categories: disease originating from the clivus, disease originating from adjacent structures, and vascular pathology.3 Masses originating from the clivus include bony metastases, chordomas, chondrosarcomas and plasmacytomas. These masses generally cause mass effect of the surrounding structures, result in bony erosion, and appear hypo- to isointense or T1-weighted imaging.4 Masses originating outside the clivus include meningiomas, nasopharyngeal cancers, craniopharyngiomas, and pituitary macroadenomas.1,5
Finally, subdural or epidural hematoma is occasionally present in the retroclival region either from trauma secondary to shearing of the bridging veins of the basilar plexus, trauma from ligament disruption and fracture, coagulopathy, or can be spontaneous.6 Clinically, patients presenting with clival masses can vary significantly, ranging from a complete lack of symptoms to headaches, cranial nerve palsies, focal neurological deficits, and endocrinopathies.3,4,7 T1 and T2 signal intensity of the clivus, contrast-enhancement characteristics, along with evaluation for underlying bony involvement and mass effect help in differentiating these etiologies.1 In our case, there was no hyperdensity on the CT without contrast to suggest hemorrhage, no underlying bony involvement, mass effect, or associated soft tissue mass, and the smooth enhancement along the posterior aspect of the clivus followed enhancement of the vasculature. The constellation of these findings ruled against a diagnosis of clival mass and supported diagnosis of a prominent retroclival venous plexus.
The development of venous anatomy at the base of the skull is especially variable and includes the cavernous sinus, the superior petrosal sinus, the inferior petrosal sinus, and the basilar venous plexus.8,9 This case likely represents a prominent basilar venous plexus in the retroclival region, which is not commonly seen on CT or MR imaging, or possibly a prominent inferior petro-occipital vein, which has been described in the literature.10 It is unlikely that this anatomic variant was the cause of our patient’s headache. Radiologists should be aware of this variable venous anatomy and distinguish between vascular variants and clival masses.
The clivus is a component of the midline skull base that exhibits characteristic, age-related T1-weighted intensity characteristics and imaging abnormalities in the area can often suggest presence of clival masses. Identifying abnormal variants of venous drainage at the base of the brain is critical in surgical decision making, as a surgery in this area can be associated with severe blood loss. Recognizing abnormal variants and differentiating anatomic variants from clival pathology will allow physicians to reassure patients regarding prognosis and future management.
Noblett D, Chang J, Shahlaie K. Prominent retroclival venous plexus, normal anatomic variant. Appl Radiol. 2018;47(7):42-44.
Prepared by Mr. Noblett while a Medical Student, Dr. Chang while an Assistant Professor in the Department of Radiology, and Dr. Shahlaie while an Associate Professor in the Department of Neurological Surgery, at the University of California, Davis, Sacramento, CA.